[split] religious debate from 'do DC's have rights'

WHOA okay didn’t notice this was PART 2… lol… i am in the process of stringing together a more on topic reply… but you know, I just saw this, didn’t know where it was coming from, but stated my comments on gays, hell, and christians in general.

I think if you are going to abide by old testament laws about homosexuality, you should follow ALL old testament laws, such ask killing people who work on the sabbath.

It’s too conveniant to filter though the old testament, ignore contradictory verses “women should be submissive in church” and use the ones that you agree with (giving gay people a hard time).

“God” would probably frown upon that. Isn’t the whole point of the New Testament (for christians) to make the Old Testament null and void, for the most part? Wasn’t that why Jesus came down in the first place, other than being some sort of ultra super sacrifice?

I’m sad that this letter appears to be fake but
snopes.com/politics/religion/drlaura.asp

It makes a great point.

Well the only thing I have to say without being horribly redundant is to ErikW, who seems like he is a Vulcan.

You are suggesting that I am insane by deviating from the norm.

I would have called you insane for drafting up plans for a helicopter a few hundred years ago… yet da vinci did just that, and he was more or less RIGHT, but no… he wasn’t right… he was wrong.

Or you would have been calling him wrong if you were a walking dictionary back then, even durring a freaking renaissance.

Like I said your petty and frivolous definitions (we cannot define reality, no one knows what anyone elses experience of “reality” is like) are shaped upon general societal agreeance about the meanings of words. The actual definitions themselves as taken literally from a dictionary mean way less than do the general consensus of a population

The general consensus of our population uses the word “kill” and all its forms when talking about: fictional characters, animals, objects, ideas, abstract concepts (time), etc…

So you are telling the people, who GIVE THE WORD MEANING IN THE FIRST PLACE, that they are wrong? They might be wrong according to convential rules invneted by a bunch of grammar nazis, but so what? If 75% of Americans talk about killing things that by your definition aren’t real… then I’d venture to say THEIR DAMN USAGE OF KILL IS CORRECT, AND YOURS IS WRONG.

All that aside, if you followed the norm a few hundred years ago, you’d be sitting here quoting BS from some sort of archaic and superstitious text, proving to me that such and such isn’t such and such becuase this little book I have says so.

If you were a sort of lawyer back then (you resemble one now) you WOULD be arguing that women don’t deserve to vote, because the constitution says all MEN were created equal… and the overall definition for man is someone of the male gender.

A woman is clearly not a man. Therefore a woman does not deserve the rights that men have.

I WIN YAY! (sarcasm, you do not know what the authors meant when using man)

I want you, to right now, either prove to me that DCs aren’t real, or revoke all your arguments.

All we have is speculation, okay? We don’t know they are real, and we don’t know that they are unreal.

we do not know

and neither do you.

If you do, prove it.

You cannot disprove the “reality” of dreams, especially given the very subjective nature of reality, which is ultimately shaped by nothing more than perception

If you can disprove the realness of DCs, by all means, do it now, shed some light on to how it’s impossible to kill them by PROVING to us that they aren’t real.

Please, disprove this argument:
When we sleep, our astral body separates from our etheric body and we visit alternate planes of existence.

Disprove it. (i realize that just because something cannot be disproven, does not make it real, as people often use that argument for God, and anything they want to say, but we have many people here trying to scientifically show that shared dreaming is possible, we have Mavromatis documenting shared hypnagogia… and we are debating a philosophical issue WHERE THERE IS NO ANSWER.)

You seem to be the only one here adamantly telling everyone they are WRONG and that you have dreams all figured out. The scientific community doesn’t even claim such things, yet.

I hope that this post didn’t come off as hostile or anything.

All I am trying to get across is that none of us know whether they are real or not. Many of us have had many experiences which would at least show shared dreaming as possible.

So the whole point is, I don’t know, and you don’t know.

hahaha

Really ??? How do you know !!! Prove it !!!

This is exactly what people are talking about !!! You go around talking like YOU speak for god. I have a lot of strongly Christian friends and none of them would make such a statement. None of them would presume to know how god would judge someone. They believe to do so is a very serious sin in its self. They would simply say that it’s not for them to judge only god can judge.

Now I am Catholic. I even went to a Catholic school. I don’t practice that religion but I do know my scripture. I think you may be in serious trouble. **Milod shakes his head ** Judging thy neighbor, pride, (lust and adultery from some of your other posts I dug up) serious trouble. This is just what I know of you so far.

Is it not possible that there are gay married couples who led good honest lives up there in heaven right now. Waiting to drive you crazy. (Assuming that’s where you go. At the rate you are going you may be in for a rude awakening.)

This may be shattering to your ego but, you are not god.

Nonsense - it’s established that what you said is nonsense, since St Paul’s time (so it was not ‘convenient’ but a fact that some things in the OT apply only to the Jews of the time, and not to Christians).
I have never suggested anyone is insane - you keep claiming things which are not true.

Holy reality, I suggest that if you don’t know about these things, just
go to a library and do some research.

There is a real way, and it’s called faith.

God is THE TRUTH. And you can KNOW HIM and EXPERIENCE. Thus you can KNOW the TRUTH. It is not based on ‘assumptions’.

Those who have searched and found Him know this.

I don’t need to (there’s lots of biblical proof etc already). It’s what the Church believes!

We know what is serious sin, mortal sin. If one dies in mortal
sin you go to hell. It is in the catholic catechism which apparently
you have never read. BTW hatred against others is a grave sin too (according to the same catechism and the church).

The Church knows how God will judge someone in mortal sin, that’s how I know. The catechism says: You cannot be united with God to get to Heaven if you sin gravely against him e.g. doing gay sex. To die in mortal sin without repenting and accepting God’s merciful love means remaining separated from him forever by our own free choice. This state is … called Hell.

As I quoted there is repentance which you seem not to be aware of.

I am in no trouble, I’m just passing on God’s message to you.
It is no sin to quote or paraphrase the Catechism. If I am in a sin through that, then the Pope is too! Funny! :cool_laugh:

And I also have to thank you, because you’re winning me heaven by
your attitude. That’s really cool. When they invent lies about you.
Like yours about lust, adultery. Nice inventions. And you yourself
judge me at the same time… Funny way to criticise people instead of
their argument. Yes I know I am not God, but I know He lives in me, thanks.

Liar !!! Really. lets see !!! *** mmm milod reaches into his truth bag***

Clark Kent wrote in sex, kissing and yup part II

Sounds pretty lustful to me !!!

MINORS !!! What would you have done to the innocent CHILD if the dream did not fade.
These 2 only took me 5 min to find.
Shall I find and post the ones where you actually calm to have had LD SEX !!! Or can I spare you THAT embarrassment.

There is that pride again. Those flames are getting hotter. :devil:

No. I do not judge you. Nor do I hate you. I am just trying to make you understand just how hypocritical, condescending, and patronizing your are being to everyone else. Since I am not the only one who thinks so. Perhaps you should take a look at that.

Interesting. Sometimes, however, there’s two people who KNOW two things that are exact opposites of each other. In fact, people’s perceptions of God have been exact opposites of each other. This would imply to me that perceptions of God would have to

  1. Not always be right or
  2. Be too complex for humans to fully understand.

If the first case, how can you be sure that it’s really God. If the second, how can you be sure you really understand him.

Either way, if God exists, assuming you know His will is pretty much the most prideful thing I can think of.

i have made a new topic - so the discussion can continue here :smile:

and a heated topic it now is wow.

I think taht DC should have rights. IF you belive they should. they are your own DC after all.

IF on the other hand you belive that they shouldnt have rights, then do so, the situation will imply more on what your choice will be i am sure.

ahh but on gods laws, who brings them into the dream along with you, your own ideas that gods laws apply even in the dream world, or the idea for the people who do not follow a religion, that laws do not.

i know that these points have been stated, i havent jsut gotten round to this topic, just trying to get back into it, so to speak

There is also a very similar topic in “theory of Lucidity”
titled “Morals in Dreams”
It can be found here
https://community.ld4all.com/t/morals-in-dreams/7423

Should Skin Cells have rights? I mean everytime you scratch or touch something you kill thousands of them at a time and unlike Dream Characters these are real lifeforms.

Yes, skin cells should have rights. Freedom of speech, freedom of the press… :cool:

One thing I don’t understand in this discussion, is what does it mean to say you shouldn’t judge others. What exactly is it and why is it wrong?

To steal your line, Monitor,

. . .is why it is still going on! I look forward to the day when you guys quit arguing over your beliefs. We all have them and they’re all pretty different so why rehash the same old stuff over and over again? I guess we just live in a day and age where people love to argue. It isn’t enough to voice your own opinion and read over others, but there must be a constant debate over little nitpicky sentences people say. Person: Quotes another person. Then writes: Yeah, but I don’t agree with you because la di da–

I am all for constructive debate, but whenever religion and spirituality are part of the issue, things can get pretty mean pretty quickly. If there’s one thing most people are passionate about, it’s their belief system.

Pheobe (from Friends): This is madness, MADNESS, I tell you! (Well, I don’t really think it’s “madness” but it is pretty repetitive.)

A show of hands please: Who ELSE gets annoyed reading this thread?

Anybody, anybody?

*Fine. I’ll let you get back to DEBATING with each other!

:bored:

It’s kind of like this.

Christian: My religion is unquestionable truth!
Catholic: NO! My religion is unquestionable truth!
Jew: Only part of your religions are true…
Buddhist: Truth lies within, not without.
Muslim: No it doesn’t! Truth lies in my religion!
Hippy: Come on guys, let’s just smoke a bowl and get along…
Agnostic: It doesn’t matter, there is no way to know who is right and wrong… give it up already.
Christian: That attitude will get you to hell!
Catholic: I agree.
Muslim: Me too!
Jew: Yes!
Buddhist: No, we are in hell already… existence is suffering.
Hippy: Yeah man, something like that… what with all this hatred and the Man cracking down on love and happiness.
Agnostic: Yeah, earth does suck.
Christian: No it doesn’t, the Bible clearly says…
Muslim: But… the Qoran clearly says…
Jew: No… the Old Testament clearly says…
5 hours later

Hehe, EXACTLY!

Gosh, it seems like just yesterday you had “May LDs: 8” in your sig and now you have 12. Wait, that WAS yesterday! Does that mean that you had 4 LDs in one night?

Sno_insul

( the only one left with a cool head )

That is true. None of us are ever going to agree with each other.

Usually when extreme religious views are involved it is not enough to simply sate your opinion and respect others who may disagree. Some feel that they must impose those views on others. Unfortunately that has been true since the beginning of time.

Here is hopeing for a actual debate and not a screeming match. :wink:

Here, here! :content:

well i remember the last time this happened it was about religion as well, i am not surprised that this topic turned out into a religious topic as well.

I agree with taht totaly, but somehow sadly i dont see that happening.

We could all agree to disagree,

If you belive that they should have Rights then say it, and then dream it, if you dont believe it then say it, then dream where they do not.

Just like religion each and everyone of us has the chance to belive in a religion, or not. just as we all have our own opions into which we are talking about now. Should they or should they not.

The answer to that is your choice, and your choice alone

Oh yeah, I think I might have had 6 yesterday…

But I’m a bit unsure on how to count them… technically if I wake from a dream and have to re-enter (this takes some skill) then that should count as 2 instead of one?

So if I have to re-enter 5 or 6 times, is that 5 or 6 separate lds? Even though I’m just re-entering the one I’m trying to stay in?

I haven’t been that liberal with my counting, but I do tend to count interupted/re-entered LDs as 2 or 3… just because I mean… if I get mad and move then the process is ruined and I can’t go back, so it takes a bit of practice and patience and experience to keep going back into these (and it also drains me… you know… my body wants me up at 5, I tell it no and sleep till 12… hehe…)

But yes as far as I know I think I had 4 yesterday… I initially told myself during the night “i think you’ve had 6, or will have 6 when you go back to sleep then get up” but since I only really remember:
church dream, I got mad at a band that sang a descriptive song about hell and tried to make them think I was Jesus… complete with walking on water and making green energy from my hands explode (that was mega cool and sort of blew the dream apart and it slowly faded back together… and I was being “Jesus” in a sarcastic way, just to make points to them, somehow, about how to not be judgemental)
ND car dream…into LD about sex.
ermm… hmm… I’ve forgotten a lot of them already… oh well… I had 4 counting having to re-enter one once.

I think having to re-enter should definitely count, since afterall it’s technically another dream after that, since you’ve woken up.

But if it does definitely count then technically I could have 10 or more LDs a night since sometimes an LD in the morning will just NOT want to stay together and I have to go back in 3-4, maybe 6 or more times.

So… go figure.

it would help if i bothered to write my dreams down though, but most aren’t really all that abnormal or exceptional… what was quite good about the ND car dream was that my car was no bigger than a small toy and I had a devil of a time trying to figure out how I was supposed to get in it and drive it around all these normal sized cars… lol… somehow I did…

and then I’d have to get out and navigate through a metal gated post office entrance (maze like in nature) to get back on the highway… it was crazy in a great way… if I didn’t waste the lucidity with sex that place would have been great to explore. But on the plus side, the sex was GOOD! (sort of!)

Now then… wow… off topic, my oh my… well… not really because of the church dream :tongue:

I’d just like to throw “think for yourself, question authority” - Timothy Leary at everyone, so many people only believe what they believe because “it’s how I was raised” well golly gee whiz, if your daddy was a cult leader think where’d you’d be right now.

If your religion is worth beliving in, it’ll withstand questioning… I “know” if there is a GOD out there, he wants you to try and MAKE YOUR OWN BELIEFS… rather than trust in an establishment that wants to control you as much as possible.

Because it’s like… how easy would it be to set up a “church” mentality to further some sort of screwed up agenda (it happens all the time) if these people are born into it blindly following it “just becuase” then it doesn’t make any sense, it could be run by the damn anti-christ for all you know… God would want you to question the hell out of any beliefs placed upon you/you were born into, to make sure that you really believe what you do, and that you aren’t being brainwashed and led off a cliff or something.

This includes questioning the Bible too… becuase it’s been in t he hands of many a corrupt man who could have altered things here and there for whatever reasons he wants.

Which in fact, I dare say probably happened in the middle ages when the church had the only copies of the Bible and wouldn’t let normal people see it… many scholars/historians believe the church of the middle ages invented the whole concept of hell to scare people into doing what they say.

So therefore, this is why I encourage you to question your beliefs, regularly… God would understand, and I think he’d want you trusting HIM rather than a preacher or an ancient book, right? How do you know his will is in the book if we “have free will” ? Someone could have altered it…

Hence trying to grow spiritually and conginitvely by QUESTIONING YOUR BELIEFS… if there’s a God I’d think he would applaud people for doing that and try and present them with the right way.

And by questioning I don’t mean “preacher, what does this mean?” … find the answers on your own… or at least, seek help from many others, not just one perosn who has been thinking for you for your whole life.

if you don’t question your beliefs, they are not YOUR beliefs to begin with, and you don’t deserve to have them

it’s people that think questioning is dangerous that are responsible for all this control right now… QUESTIONING THE GOVERNMENT IS WRONG, LET’S LET THEM DO WHATEVER THEY WANT TO DO AND BLINDLY WAVE OUR FLAGS, THEY CARE ABOUT THE COMMON MAN!!!

You know? And that carries into religion too… thankfully we don’t have many christians blowing things up around here (every now and then it happens) but I mean… what if you just so happened to be raised by a bunch of KKK southern fundamentalists who like to blow up abortion clinics?

Well… this is why we QUESTION AUTHORITY, and this is why in order to think for ourselves, we have to.

Until we do so we are just reflections of our envrionment, of our teachers, parents, religion, and government, we are thinking how they think we should think, and we are so naive and young that we do not realize this… therefore in order to grow as a person you have to question your beliefs.

Really the best thing to do is listen to whatever the opposite of you is (like an athiest) says, and really CONSIDER what he is saying, don’t dismiss it as nonsense… really try and see where his reasoning is coming from, why he has it, understand his questions, try and answer them without thumping a holy book at him.

If you all wanted to know why I believe what I just said and I told you “because Timothy Leary told me to” you’d be mega pissed off and would think I’m an idiot, yet it’s okay to use the Bible to end any argument someone raises? NO, it isn’t, try and reason with them on their level, try and understand what they are asking, try and do something thinking outside the box, and outside the book… you know? I also realize that since most religions are largely based upon archaic text that you ARE going to have to rely on it some, but it does no good to try and hold a religious debate with someone who is not from your religion by quoting things from a book at him.

I could write a holy book that says “I am always right” and then whenever someone disagreed with me I’d direct them to the Book of Holy Reality, verse 1, chapter 1… but that doesn’t do anything at all.

So I mean… I can see the validity of CHRISTIANS debating what different Bible verses might mean, but when you are trying to prove the existence of God to someone (which you absolutely cannot do, so I don’t see why you’d try and do so) it doesn’t do a lot of good to quote a book.

Now if you were talking to someone about forgiveness, it’d be great to take a Jesus quote there, becuase that man knew a thing or two about forgiveness, he had some good teachings… and it doesn’t necessarily limit someone to adhering to your religion.

but anyway…

You have to learn empathy, you have to learn to understand other belief structures, understand why people think the way they do and believe the way they do… you have to listen to what they say, and consider it rationally, try and think of it from a non-biased viewpoint…

You don’t just say “no that isn’t true… such and such verse says so, argument over, I win.”

You know?

Hopefully this isn’t lost on some of you, this is my third question things rant and I haven’t seemed to get any responses to it…

at least a few people should understand what I’m talking about.

It’s kind of like that story of the 3 blind men who are trying to describe an elephant… one feels a trunk and says “surely an elephant is very long” and one feels it’s feet and says “an elephant is much like a tree” and well… things like that.

But ultimately, though they can speculate , they still DO NOT KNOW WHAT AN ELEPHANT IS ACTUALLY LIKE.

Much in the same way, we can speculate about God, but none of us really know… all religions are are peoples ways of trying to put the un-understandable into easy to relate to terminlogy.

I mean afterall, they call god HE… they speak of him as some sort of entity bound to a body…

I don’t see that at all… if there were a God I think there is way more to it than that… but it doesn’t matter what I think… the point is there are thousands of religions, constantly, all of them hoping to reach the same result, but all just human attempts at understanding the not understandable.

Think of God as water and religion as variously different shaped cups.
(i wish i came up with that but I got it from someone else)

Not that any of our ideas are really exclusive to us though.